2009-10: McEneny played in four games for the CCHL's Burlington Cougars and spent the season with the Hamilton Junior Bulldogs midget AAA team in Ontario. He had 1 assist with the Cougars. The Bulldogs competed in the 2010 OHL Cup and in four games McEneny was scoreless with 6 penalty minutes. He was selected by Kitchener in the 2nd round (34th overall) of the 2010 OHL Priority Draft.
2010-11: McEneny played 44 games for the Kitchener Rangers in his first OHL season. He had 4 assists and was minus-five with 15 penalty minutes. Kitchener finished second in the Midwest Division and faced Plymouth in a seven-game first round playoff series. McEneny played in four games in the series with the Whalers with no points nor penalty minutes.
2011-12: McEneny skated in two games for Kitchener – suffering a season-ending knee injury. Despite his injury, he was featured in Central Scouting's mid-term rankings (211- limited viewing) but was not among the 210 North American skaters in Central Scouting's final rankings and was not selected in the 2012 NHL Draft. He had 2 assists and was plus-three with 4 penalty minutes in his only action before the injury. He signed an entry-level three-year contract with Vancouver in September 2012 before returning to Kitchener.