2008-09: Tyler Pitlick played for Centennial High School in Minnesota. In 25 games, He scored 31 goals and added 33 assists for 64 points. he was a finalist for the Mr. Hockey Award given to the top high school player in Minnesota.
2009-10: Freshman for University of Minnesota – Mankato. In 38 games for the Mavericks, Pitlick scored 11 goals and added 8 assists for 19 points. Nephew of former NHL player, Lance Pitlick.
2010-11: After being drafted by the Oilers in the second round of the 2010 NHL Draft, Pitlick left Minnesota State to play for Medicine Hat in the WHL. He skated in 56 games for the Tigers, suffering a season-ending ankle injury. He scored 27 goals with 35 assists and was +4 with 31 PMs for the Tigers. He signed a three-year, entry-level contract with Edmonton in April 2011.
2011-12: Pitlick steadily made the adjustment to pro hockey as a 20-year-old in his first season with Edmonton’s AHL affiliate Oklahoma City. He skated in 62 of 76 games for the Barons, playing both wing and center, and scored 7 goals with 6 assists. He had 10 of his 23 points in the last two months of the season – finishing the year minus-one with 28 penalty minutes. Oklahoma City finished first in the West Division and reached the playoff semifinals. Pitlick skated in 13 of 14 playoff games and was plus-two with 2 goals, 5 assists and 2 penalty minutes.
2012-13: Pitlick was limited to 44 games in his second AHL season due to injuries and the presence of several NHL forwards in the Oklahoma City lineup early in the year due to the NHL lockout. He scored 3 goals with 7 assists and was -7 with 10 penalty minutes. The Barons finished third in the South Division and reached the Western Conference finals. Pitlick played in 16 of 17 playoff games, scoring 2 goals with 4 assists, and was +1 with 8 penalty minutes.
2013-14: Pitlick made his NHL debut in a game against Montreal in October and scored his first NHL goal two games later during a three-game stint with the Oilers — spending most of his third pro season with Edmonton AHL affiliate Oklahoma City — and re-joined the NHL club in March, skating in seven games. In 10 NHL games he scored 1 goal and was -2 with no penalty minutes. Despite again missing time due to injury he skated in 39 AHL games with the Barons and scored 8 goals with 14 assists, finishing +6 with 10 penalty minutes. Oklahoma City finished third in the West Division and was swept by Calder Cup champion Texas in a first round playoff series. Pitlick had no points nor penalties and was an even plus/minus in two playoff games.
Pitlick has pro size, great hands, a plus shot, and sees the ice quite well. He is noted for his hockey sense and defensive awareness and does not shy away from the physical element of the game. Pitlick was perceived as a pure goal scorer when he was drafted but his offensive numbers have been limited at the pro level. A series of injuries have kept him off the ice for long stretches during his four-year career — the most recent being a spleen injury suffered in a game against Calgary on New Years' Eve 2014. HIs determination to overcome those setbacks speaks to his character but the time off has slowed his development.
Pitlick attended training camp with Edmonton before being assigned to Oilers AHL affiliate Oklahoma City to start the 2014-15 season. He was subsequently called up by Edmonton in December and skated in 14 games in a lower line role before suffering a lacerated spleen in a game against the Flames. Now in his fourth pro season, Pitlick has been plagued by injury during his pro career. As a result, he never developed into the scorer envisioned when Edmonton drafted him in the second round. He appears capable of being a a serviceable two-way forward at the NHL level one day. .