Carl Neill


Montreal Quebec

Currently Playing In:






Eligible for draft:









5th round (144th overall), 2015


214 lbs.

<<<<<<< Updated upstream

2011-12: Carl Neill played midget AAA hockey with the Saint-Eustache Vikings in Quebec. In 42 regular season games he scored 2 goals with 19 assists and 34 penalty minutes. Neil was selected by Val-d’Or in the first round (ninth overall) in the 2012 QMJHL Entry Draft.  After requesting a trade he was obtained by the first-year Sherbrooke Phoenix in August 2012. 

2012-13: Neill skated in 61 of 68 regular season games for Sherbrooke in his first QMJHL season and was the leading scorer amongst Phoenix defensemen. He was an assistant captain for Canada Quebec at the 2013 U 17 World Hockey Challenge. Neill scored 3 goals with 17 assists and was -19 with 30 penalty minutes. Sherbrooke finished last in the West Division, securing a playoff spot despite winning 21 games, and was swept by Baie-Comeau in a first-round series. Neill scored 1 goal with 1 assist and was -4 with 8 penalty minutes in four playoff games. He scored 2 goals with 1 assist and 4 penalty minutes in six games for Canada Quebec. 

2013-14: Neill played for the Canada U18 team at the 2013 Ivan Hlinka Memorial Tournament in August before returning to Sherbrooke for a second season. In 65 games he scored 4 goals with 18 assists and was -31 with 58 penalty minutes. The Phoenix finished last in the West Division, missing the playoffs with the league’s worst record. Neill had an even plus/minus with no points nor penalty minutes in five games for Canada’s gold medal squad at the Ivan Hlinka tournament. Canada shutout the USA, 4-0, in the gold medal game. 

2014-15: Neill attended the Calgary Flames’ prospect camp but was not allowed to participate due to a heart issue. Following a surgical procedure in the off-season, he had a breakout season for Sherbrooke in his third season with the Phoenix. He scored 14 goals with 26 assists, trailing only 17-year-old Jeremy Roy for the points lead amongst Sherbrooke defensemen, and was -16 with 77 penalty minutes in 63 games. The Phoenix finished third in the West Division, falling to Charlottetown in a first-round series. Neill scored 1 goal with 5 assists and was -4 with 4 penalty minutes in six playoff games. In his second year of draft eligibility, Neill was not among the 210 North American skaters in the Central Scouting final rankings when he was selected by Vancouver in the fifth round (144th overall) in the 2015 NHL Draft. 

Talent Analysis

Neill has a fairly decent shot that he is not afraid to unleash. He can rush the puck and has good passing skills but his decision making is sometimes called into question. Mobility may be another concern and he will need to improve his speed and positioning to keep up with the pro game. Neill has some rough edges to smooth out and should be considered a long-term project.

Will return to Sherbrooke for his fourth season with the team. Should be among the leadership group of the team and play important minutes in all situations. Has a long way to go to earn a contract with the Canucks organization and will have a lot to prove in 2015-16.

QMJHL’s top 10 NHL properties at defense all selected at the 2015 NHL Draft

by Kristopher Bras
Thomas Chabot - Saint John Sea Dogs

Photo: Saint John Sea Dogs defenseman and Ottawa Senators prospect Thomas Chabot’s points per game average is fifth among defensemen in the QMJHL in 2015-16 (courtesy of Francois Laplante/FreestylePhoto/Getty Images)



The QMJHL is not exactly known for strong defense, but the league’s defensive corps were heavily repped at the 2015 NHL Draft. All 10 of the defenders chosen at that draft comprise this season’s top-10 QMJHL defenseman—although not in the same order that they were selected last June. Read more»

The Vancouver Canucks are benefiting from CHL prospects

by Curtis Coulter
Carl Neill - Vancouver Canucks

Photo: Vancouver Canucks prospect and Sherbrooke Phoenix captain Carl Neill fits the profile of the steady stay-at-home defender but his offensive ability should not be underestimated (courtesy of Francois Laplante/Freestyle Photo/Getty Images)



The Vancouver Canucks have done a fine job of re-stocking their prospect pool over the last few seasons and the good scouting and smart drafting has finally begun to bear fruit. Former CHL stars Bo Horvat, Jake Virtanen and Jared McCann are all now full time NHL players. The wisdom of having Virtanen and McCann in the NHL this season could be debated but they should play important roles for the Canucks for many years to come. Here is a look at the Canucks prospects currently playing in the junior ranks of North America. 

Read more»

2015 NHL Draft: Vancouver Canucks draft review

by Peter Prohaska
Brock Boeser - Vancouver Canucks

Photo: Minnesota native Brock Boeser was one of the most dangerous scorers in the 2015 draft class (courtesy of Bruce Bennett/Getty Images)



The Vancouver Canucks prospects pool might be the least of the franchise’s worries at this moment in time. Ranked right in the middle of the league prior to the 2015 NHL Draft, the group boasts some areas of strength but fails to inspire much confidence on the whole. There is some quality (especially at center) and some quantity (especially on defense) and the Canucks added more of both to the prospect pool. Read more»

2015 NHL Draft: Winners, losers, and in between from this weekend’s draft

by David Hahn
Mathew Barzal - New York Islanders - 2015 NHL Draft

Photo: Seattle Thunderbirds forward Mathew Barzal was ranked as a top-10 talent, but fell to the New York Islanders at 16th overall in the 2015 NHL Draft (courtesy of Jeff Vinnick/NHLI via Getty Images)



With the 2015 NHL Draft in the rear-view mirror, hope and optimism abounds among NHL organizations and their fans. It’s truly a great time of year, and with 211 picks in the books, this draft should be remembered for years to come. Read more»

2012-13 QMJHL season preview

by Kevin Forbes

Nathan MacKinnon - Halifax Mooseheads

Photo: 2013 prospect Nathan MacKinnon leads a talented Halifax Mooseheads team that should contend for the QMJHL title in 2012-13 (courtesy of Dave Connelly/HF)

 As is always the case, the new QMJHL season approaches with a clear shift in the balance of power across the league. The 2011-12 season featured an extremely strong TELUS East Division which eventually led to the Memorial Cup champion Shawinigan Cataractes.

Read more»